Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.) Montauk Hwy, Shirley

“Island Wide Insurance Agency” is a great place to do business; I’ve been a client of theirs for almost 10 years. Everyone in the office is extremely educated & helpful, ensuring that all of your needs are met. I would highly recommend working with them to get you the right insurance policy.

I was looking to switch my insurance company because they raised my price by an extremely crazy number. In during research I came across Island wide insurance. I called them for a quote after reading the reviews from everyone. I was so glad I did. Joe was very professional and attentive. He answered all my questions and gave me a quote that was almost half the price that the other insurance companies was charging for the same coverage. It was clearly a no brainer. Thank you Joe.

I’ve had insurance with them for years and never had a problem. I am very pleased with their business. They have reasonable rates, friendly staff and are very helpful. Definitely recommend them!!

My experience with island wide insurance in Shirley New York is the best they’re not just my insurance agents They are family where on a first name basis Joey James and Kelly 💜 are very professional and very knowledgeable in every detail when it comes to saving their customers money they have nothing to gain but loyal customers so they are going to find you the best price to fit your needs I’ve been dealing with them for over two years and I wouldn’t go anywhere else they’re honest and truthful and if you can find a better quote somewhere else they will tell you to go for it but I haven’t and I’m not going anywhere

Joe's a awesome dude, definitely should go check these guys out if you want to get some good prices on Insurance

Great insurance company. I have been with island wide/stop insurance for 8 years now. I get a great deal & it’s always a low down payment. Kelly & her team are not only extremely friendly & helpful but they go out of their way to help. Every year they remind me with plenty of notice that it’s time to renew. I live over an hour away from them but I continue to renew with them because I’m extremely happy with their service. I’m also glad that I don’t have to drive all the way out there to sign papers. I’m very happy with them.

What a great insurance company. James and his team are amazing, willing to help you with any question or issue you may have. They respond quickly and really work hard on getting you the best policy at the best price. Thank you guys so much.

Have been with them for years and they always give great and helpful service with finding the best policy prices and with providing documents later on whenever needed with speed; including when insurance company had failed to mail out the new card.

Joe and James are a pleasure to work with. Super friendly and professional. They will go out of their way to get you the best price. I switched from geico to come over to them. I Highly recommend !

Joe and his staff at Island Wide are the best! He was able to save me a ton of money off my car insurance and explained everything step-by-step step! So glad I switched … Go for an awesome Ride when you have Island Wide on your side!!

Joe was so helpful. I was on a time crunch and he stayed after hours to get me my policy. On top of it all it was cheaper than other quotes I received and supplied me with better coverage. Thanks Joe!

James was great and extremely helpful. He did excellent with my general liability and commercial auto policy. Thanks James

I have been coming here for quite a few years. They have been very friendly and helpful every time I come in. Easy and quick. I wouldn’t go anywhere else

In today’s world, where customer service & kindness is almost extinct Joe & his staff at Island wide set the bar high. From start to finish they communicate and instill confidence that you are in good hands. I have used Joe and his team for the past 7 years & have never once been disappointed. Unbeatable policy prices and the nicest people around. Thanks Island wide for all you do!

I have been with Island Wide Ins. Agency for a few years now and they are by far the best insurance company I have ever dealt with. James & Joe are so friendly and so helpful. I wouldn’t choose anyone else when it comes to my insurance! Even Kelly the administrative assistance is so nice and responsive. Best prices & great quality!

I cant say enough good things about this insurance agency. I work in alot of places where there is constant turnover but Kelly, James, and Joe are all friendly constants here, delivering the very standard of customer service. You wont regret comming here for a quote, i've been a customer here for years and so has much of my family!